Between These Walls - Reading Group Guide

Printable version

Discussion Questions

1. To which character did you most relate? Why?
   
   
2. Hunter experiences growth during the novel. When does his growth begin: before or after his relationship with Gabe begins? Does growth occur after his secret is exposed to the public? Does Gabe experience growth as well?
   
   
3. Hunter has kept his sexual attractions a secret for 14 years. Was there a time in your life when you found it easier to build walls around yourself than to face the truth?
   
   
4. Much of the story occurs against the backdrop of a cold Ohio winter and the construction of a new home. How does the author use seasons or events to reflect the internal processes of Hunter and Ellen?
   
   
5. Jesse Barlow, a supporting character, also appeared in John Herrick’s novel From The Dead. How has Jesse grown since then? How might Jesse’s battle have changed his outlook or prepared him to support Hunter?
   
   
6. Can you identify parallels between Ellen Krieger’s silent struggle and that of Hunter?
   
   
7. Which chapter do you consider your favorite? Why? Which chapters do you believe reveal the most about Hunter, Gabe and Ellen, respectively?
   
   
8. How would you define Hunter’s relationship with Kara versus his relationship with Gabe? How does each relationship affect Hunter’s personal growth?
   
   
9. In the Prologue, we are introduced to a young Hunter Carlisle. Do you think the Prologue’s events helped shape who Hunter is today? If so, in what ways?
   
   
10. Hunter has solid faith, yet he harbored a secret. Do you consider his actions hypocritical?
    
    
11. In Chapter 22, Hunter recalls a classmate, Christopher Patton, and regrets he allowed Christopher to face humiliation alone. Are there events in your life you wish you had handled differently?
    
    
12. In Chapter 35, Hunter confides in his pastor. Do you feel his pastor handled the scenario in an appropriate manner? If you were in Hunter’s shoes, what would have helped you during that discussion?
    
    
13. In Chapter 36, Hunter reveals his secret to his parents. How do you feel his parents reacted to the news? How might sudden, similar news from your child affect you?
    
    
14. How has Hunter’s relationship with his father impacted Hunter’s growth processes during childhood and adulthood?
    
    
15. In Chapters 4, 9, 10, 22, 24, 29 and 43, Hunter recalls events from his past. How did those events help shape who he is today?
    
    
16. How do religion, emotion and sex drive Hunter? How do these factors seem to drive other characters, or do they?